Poor reenactment of a great photo

On the way back from a camping trip on the North Shore or Minnesota (photo of that to eventaully appear in this space), we stopped at Banning State Park, the same place we did a few years ago. I made a wonderful photo that is not printed huge in our house, the kids love to look at it. So they all demanded we find the same rocks and re-enact the photo today. Here's my mediocre photo of their stellar effort. The original:

and today: